| 1894-1942 | Wm. H. Meldrum [1] |
| 1942-1953 | Richard W. Wamsley [1] |
| 1953-1959 | William James Clague [1] |
| 1959-1963 | Charles Lee Roy Pedersen [1] |
| 1963-1968 | Wesley Hugh Smith [1] |
| 1968-1969 | Charles Hamilton Brittain [1] |
| 1969-1970 | Ralph Bonaker [1] |
| 1970-1981 | Leonard Faulkner Neils |
| 1981-1985 | Gerald J. Gallagher |
| 1986-1989 | George Latimer Campbell |
| 1986-1990 | Mary Ann Catherine Mroczka [2] |
| 1988-1996 | Robert Livingston Shearer |
| 1996-1998 | Louise Parsons Pietsch |
| 1998-2001 | Elizabeth Ruth Broyles |
| 2002-2003 | Edwin Dale Baker [3] |
| 2003-2012 | Kathleen Lesley McCloghrie |
| 2013-2015 | Katherine Herron-Piazza [3] |
| 2016-2017 | José Martínez [4] |
| 2017-2022 | Juan Perez [4] |
| 2023-2023 | Dr. Robert D. Flanagan [3] |
| 2023- | Richard Suero |
[1] Shared with Christ Church, Patterson
[2] Priest Associate, Eastern Dutchess Ministries
[3] Interim
[4] Priest in Charge, Harlem Valley Regional Ministries
